UK light-heavyweight Buatsi earned a win yet disappointing debut to his career under new promoters with a decision win over Zach Parker in the Manchester arena.
The Olympic medal winner's work rate seemingly secured him a judges' verdict in a close 10-round fight at the boxing arena.
But the challenger found success, connecting with powerful clean blows in a fight where the techniques never quite clicked, with frequent clinching spoiling the action.
The officials had it 96-94 to Buatsi, with the remaining official a even score.
"It wasn't my finest showing but what do champions do? They succeed," Buatsi stated in the ring as he was met by disapproval from the audience.
The British fighter bounced back after his maiden career setback - an epic battle with his previous opponent in February - to secure a 20th career victory.
Various analysts believed Parker, 31, should have been awarded the win but the Derbyshire fighter endured the second setback of his 28-match career.
The Champion Earns Win in Dull Affair
The fighter's advancement has slowed in the past few years through contract problems and long spells of inactivity.
Once tipped as the next star of British boxing, he now finds himself trying to fulfil that early promise - perhaps in what seems like a final roll of the dice - under new promotional backing.
He began cautiously, with both competitors willing to be aggressive in a tentative opening few rounds.
The challenger, whose single earlier setback came at super middleweight against his former opponent in 2022 after suffering a hand injury mid-fight, was participating in his second bout at the higher weight class.
By the halfway stage, Parker had stayed in contention, making life awkward for Buatsi, who worked behind a tight guard to edge the more effective stanzas.
The audience's tolerance diminished because of frequent holding, with Parker going down multiple occasions during close exchanges.
Parker finished the stronger, but many rounds were hard to judge. Nevertheless, ex-champion Carl Frampton - working with Dazn - had it significantly in favor for the challenger, awarding Buatsi just only one stanza.
The victor progresses, but with the caliber of hard hitter Benavidez, and Eastern European fighter Dmitry Bivol leading the category, the road to world glory - on this evidence - still looks steep.
Hatton Tribute Inspires Manchester Derby Contest
In the secondary fight, Arthur defeated Bradley Rea by split-decision in a terrific all-Manchester fight to capture the European light-heavyweight championship.
The stadium grew hushed for a extremely emotional memorial ahead of the contest as ten bells tolled in honor of Manchester's own Ricky Hatton, who died aged 46 in recently.
It was the initial significant broadcast boxing event in the location since Hatton's passing. As the final chime faded, the silence gave way to a chant of "only one Hatton".
The action during the bout matched the feeling. The eventual winner was knocked down by a significant blow squarely on the chin in the second round, standing uncertainly to his footing on the count of eight.
But the red-colored equipment of Arthur soon pressed ahead again. Across the ring, the opponent - in competitive blue - was marked up quickly, heavy swelling developing under his face as the pair landed powerful shots.
The challenger, twenty-seven, connected with strong blows but the champion, 34, responded in kind with powerful upward punches as the action hardly diminished over 12 rounds.
The victor edged the decision with official scores of 114-114, narrow lead and wider gap, but both fighters were relentless and full of heart, everything their inspiration Hatton represented.